Know what is on your site before a plaintiff’s firm does.Free website scanScan Your Site
Log in Sign up Book a demo
Home› News› CalPrivacy Orders Hertz to Pay $1.55M Over Ignored…
NEWS

CalPrivacy Orders Hertz to Pay $1.55M Over Ignored Opt-Out Signals, Tells Filson to Halt Ad-Tech Sharing

California’s privacy regulator has issued two more enforcement decisions centred on the same failure: websites that keep feeding visitor data to advertising technology companies after the visitor’s browser has said no.

Nov 17, 2026 9 min read

California’s privacy regulator has issued two more enforcement decisions centred on the same failure: websites that keep feeding visitor data to advertising technology companies after the visitor’s browser has said no. On 17 November 2026, the California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) announced that its Board had ordered The Hertz Corporation to pay a $1.55 million administrative fine and overhaul how its Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites and apps handle opt-out requests. In a separate decision, the Board ordered outdoor clothing maker C.C. Filson Co. to pay $217,987 and to stop device-based sales and sharing of Californians’ personal information to ad-tech companies unless it certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it has fixed its practices.

TL;DR

  • CalPrivacy’s Board adopted a stipulated order requiring Hertz to pay $1.55 million over alleged failures to honour opt-out preference signals such as Global Privacy Control, to explain signal handling in its privacy policy, and to avoid a confusing cookie opt-out flow.
  • Filson must pay $217,987, reduced because of documented inability to pay a multi-million dollar fine, and must stop device-based ad-tech sales and sharing within 30 days unless it certifies compliance first.
  • Both companies settled without admitting liability, and both orders impose three years of recurring testing, audit or training duties.

Rows of grey rental cars in a California parking lot at golden hour, with palm trees, dry hills and a faint shimmer of signal waves in the air

What the Board decided and when

Both matters were resolved by settlement rather than a contested hearing. The Board signed orders of decision on 6 November 2026 adopting stipulated final orders negotiated with CalPrivacy’s Enforcement Division, and the decisions took effect immediately. The agency publicised them in a press release on 17 November.

That procedural detail matters for how the facts should be read. The orders contain sections titled “factual findings,” but they are settlement documents. Hertz admitted only background facts about its business, its California footprint and its cooperation; it neither admits nor denies the remaining findings and does not admit any violation of the California Consumer Privacy Act. Filson’s order has the same structure. The violations described below are the Enforcement Division’s allegations, which the companies agreed to resolve.

The Hertz case: three alleged failures

The Hertz stipulated final order covers 1 July 2023 to 25 August 2026. It says Hertz placed tracking technologies from Meta, Google, Pinterest, LinkedIn, Microsoft, TikTok, The Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Adobe, Amazon, Criteo and others on its digital properties, making identifiers and rental details such as car rental dates available for cross-context behavioural advertising. The order notes that some of those companies are registered data brokers and that some engaged in cookie syncing, which links identifiers across ad-tech systems and deepens profiling.

Against that background, the Enforcement Division alleged three problems:

  • Ignored opt-out preference signals. For part of the period, Hertz allegedly did not configure its sites to detect and honour signals such as Global Privacy Control, and kept selling and sharing data with ad-tech firms and data brokers after receiving them. The order cites Civil Code section 1798.120(d) and sections 7025(c)(1) and 7026(f) of the regulations, and stresses that California has required businesses to honour such signals since 2020.
  • A privacy policy that said nothing about signals. For part of the period, the policy allegedly failed to explain how Hertz processes opt-out preference signals and how consumers can use them, as section 7011(e)(3)(F) requires.
  • A misleading cookie window. On Dollar.com and Thrifty.com, the “Manage Cookies” window displayed every toggle, including advertising cookies, as already switched off. If a visitor closed the window without clicking “Save Changes,” the settings reverted to defaults that allowed advertising cookies. The agency said this added a non-obvious step and used choice architecture that may have been confusing, contrary to section 7004(a)(3)–(4).

The order credits Hertz with cooperating, meeting the agency multiple times and taking prompt corrective action during the investigation.

What Hertz must now do

The $1.55 million is due within 60 days of the decision’s effective date. The non-monetary terms run for three years and are more instructive for other businesses than the fine:

  1. Quarterly tracker inventory. Scan all Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty domains, subdomains and apps at least quarterly to keep a complete inventory of tracking technologies that sell or share personal information.
  2. Check the signal before tags load. Configure properties so that a GPC signal is checked before any tracking technology that sells or shares data is loaded, and follow vendor and tag manager instructions, including sending restricted data use flags to service providers where needed.
  3. Test like an engineer. Test opt-out handling quarterly and whenever a new tracker is added, in staging and production, across browsers and mobile platforms, for every tag management container, for server-side and client-side technologies, for known and unknown users, and for first-time visitors with no stored consent state.
  4. Gate new trackers. Run an internal review before onboarding any third party that receives personal information, confirming a CCPA-compliant contract and working opt-out configuration.
  5. Do not outsource trust. Hertz may not rely solely on what its service providers or consent management platform tell it, and must independently check at least twice a year that those tools process CCPA requests correctly and on time.
  6. Report signal metrics. When publishing annual CCPA request metrics, separately count opt-out requests that arrived through opt-out preference signals.

Hertz must also test its request methods quarterly, review its CCPA practices within 180 days, and finish required system changes within 180 days. Lara Kehoe Hoffman, CalPrivacy’s Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement, said companies “cannot ignore those choices or shift responsibility to others,” a line that lands squarely on businesses that assume their cookie banner tooling handles compliance by default.

The Filson stipulated final order covers 2 March 2025 to 31 March 2026 and describes a more basic breakdown. According to the Enforcement Division, Filson’s website had no “Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information” link or approved alternative. Its privacy policy pointed consumers to a toll-free number, an email address and a customer care web page, and none of them worked properly: some callers and emailers were not helped, and the link led to a “page not found” error. The policy also sent opt-out seekers to a choices link that did not exist on the site and to outside industry and government resources, instead of providing the two or more opt-out methods the regulations require.

The most technically significant allegation concerns opt-out signals. Filson allegedly shared identifiers and browsing history with companies including Meta, Google, Pinterest, and registered data brokers Elevar and Zeta Global, both through the browser and through direct server-to-server connections. The order says a valid signal required Filson to stop cross-context behavioural advertising for that browser and any profile it could associate with it, including on the server side. For browser-based sharing, it could have stopped transmissions or, for genuine service providers, attached a restricted data processing or limited data use flag. The agency says it did neither, and counted at least five prohibited sales or shares each time an opted-out consumer visited. Teams that moved tracking server-side should note this, because consent gating for server-side tracking needs its own design.

An unusual remedy: stop selling until you certify

Filson’s order opens by noting that the Enforcement Division was prepared to seek a multi-million dollar fine but reviewed confidential financial information supporting Filson’s claimed inability to pay. The fine was set at $217,987 instead.

The non-monetary terms carry the weight. Filson must cease device-based sales and sharing of all Californians’ personal information to ad-tech companies within 30 days of the decision’s effective date. It may resume only after an officer or director signs a certification, under penalty of perjury, that it complies with the order’s audit, opt-out, onboarding and training terms. If it certifies within the 30 days, it never has to stop. Filson must also audit its signal handling quarterly for three years, add a compliant opt-out link and an interactive request form, and train staff who handle CCPA requests within 30 days and annually after that.

Why these decisions matter beyond rental cars and jackets

Opt-out preference signals have been the agency’s most consistent enforcement theme, and the remedies are converging into a recognisable template: inventory trackers, check the signal before tags fire, test in production across browsers, verify vendors independently, and contract properly with every recipient. The Hertz terms on vendor tools also echo the agency’s earlier guidance on limiting and opting out under the CCPA.

Contracts are part of the story. Sending data to an ad-tech firm with a restricted processing flag only helps if the recipient is genuinely bound as a CCPA service provider. Without that contract, the transfer is likely a sale or share regardless of flags.

The stakes are rising. The press release notes that California’s Opt Me Out Act, which takes effect in January 2027, requires browsers operating in California to offer easy-to-use opt-out preference signals, so far more visitors will send them. Courts are also reading tracking cases through the CCPA, as the Allison v. PHH Mortgage ruling showed. For a sense of scale, both fines sit within the range of recent CCPA fines, which CalPrivacy lists alongside its $2.975 million FedEx decision and $1.35 million Tractor Supply decision.

Frequently asked questions

Did Hertz admit it broke the law?

No. Hertz admitted background facts about its business and cooperation, neither admitted nor denied the remaining findings, and did not admit liability. The fine and obligations are settlement terms adopted by the Board.

Is honouring Global Privacy Control optional in California?

No. Both orders state that California has required businesses to treat opt-out preference signals as valid opt-out requests since 2020, now under section 7025 of the CCPA regulations.

Does moving tracking server-side avoid these rules?

No. The Filson order treats server-to-server transfers to ad-tech firms as sales or shares that must stop for any profile associated with a browser sending an opt-out signal.

Why was Filson’s fine so much lower than Hertz’s?

The order says the agency reviewed confidential financial information supporting Filson’s claim that it could not pay a multi-million dollar fine, and set the amount with that in mind.

The signal is the request

The common thread is simple: when a browser sends an opt-out signal, California treats it as the consumer saying no, and every tag, server call and vendor downstream has to hear it. Hertz and Filson both had tools in place. What they allegedly lacked was proof that those tools actually worked, and proof is now what CalPrivacy orders companies to produce every quarter.