Know what is on your site before a plaintiff’s firm does.Free website scanScan Your Site
Log in Sign up Book a demo
Home› News› Plaintiffs Ask Judge to Sanction Meta Over Privilege…
NEWS

Plaintiffs Ask Judge to Sanction Meta Over Privilege Claims in Teen Social Media Addiction MDL

Lawyers for the school districts and young people suing Meta over teen social media addiction have asked a federal judge in Oakland to punish the company for how it used attorney-client privilege during discovery.

Nov 17, 2026 8 min read

Lawyers for the school districts and young people suing Meta over teen social media addiction have asked a federal judge in Oakland to punish the company for how it used attorney-client privilege during discovery. Their motion, filed on November 13, 2026 in the consolidated litigation known as MDL 3047, says Meta’s own court-ordered re-review has reversed its privilege calls on about 93% of the documents examined so far. That figure is often repeated as “93% of documents in the case” were improperly withheld, which overstates it: it is Meta’s cumulative downgrade rate in the re-review to date, and Meta disputes that a downgrade means a document was wrongly withheld. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers is scheduled to hear the motion on December 14. Every claim of misconduct below is an allegation that the court has not yet ruled on.

TL;DR

  • Personal injury and school district plaintiffs filed a motion on November 13, 2026 asking the court to sanction Meta under Rule 37 and its inherent authority for alleged privilege abuses in the social media adolescent addiction MDL.
  • The motion says Meta has downgraded about 93% of documents in a court-ordered re-review, cumulatively, and asks for a jury instruction, limits on Meta’s evidentiary objections and clawbacks, and fees.
  • Meta says it acted in good faith and calls the motion a litigation tactic; the hearing is set for December 14, 2026 before Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, ahead of a school district trial expected in February.

Oil-painting style empty courtroom lit by golden window light, with towering stacks of documents covered in black redaction bars

The case and the motion

The litigation is In re: Social Media Adolescent Addiction/Personal Injury Products Liability Litigation, No. 4:22-md-03047-YGR-PHK, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers presides, and Magistrate Judge Peter H. Kang is assigned to the case. Reuters reports that about 4,300 cases are consolidated before Judge Gonzalez Rogers, brought by individuals and school districts who claim Meta, Alphabet’s Google, TikTok and Snap designed their platforms to be addictive to young users. Meta has broadly denied the claims and says it has worked to protect teens.

The motion, docketed as ECF 3690 and available on the CourtListener docket, is titled “Motion to Sanction Meta for Privilege Abuses.” It was filed by co-lead counsel Lexi Hazam of Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein and Previn Warren of Motley Rice. The parties stipulated that it can be heard at the December 14, 2026 case management conference at 9:00 a.m. Pacific by videoconference, subject to the court’s approval, with Meta’s response due December 2 and the reply due December 7.

What plaintiffs say happened

According to the motion, the dispute has built up over more than a year:

  • Discovery cutoff. By the April 4, 2025 fact discovery cutoff, Meta had withheld about 130,000 documents in full as privileged and redacted thousands more.
  • First re-review. Months later, Meta re-reviewed and released roughly 65,000 of the fully withheld documents, after plaintiffs had finished depositions and served expert reports.
  • The August 2026 trial. During a trial of state attorneys general’s claims in the MDL, the court called Meta’s redactions in one exhibit “entirely inappropriate” and rejected as “far too broad-based” the theory that a lawyer checking a business presentation for accuracy made it privileged.
  • Priority review. At a September 22 conference the court had plaintiffs pick 300 of their most important documents. Plaintiffs say only 81 of Meta’s original privilege calls on those documents survived unchanged.
  • Special master. At an October 9 hearing the court rejected Meta’s proposal to use artificial intelligence to narrow the set of documents needing re-review. Meta then agreed to independent oversight, and the court appointed retired Magistrate Judge Suzanne H. Segal as special master.

The court-ordered protocol requires Meta to re-review both withheld and redacted documents, produce downgrades weekly at an average pace of at least 20,000 documents a week, and finish by December 30, 2026. The special master reviews weekly random samples of 200 documents that Meta still claims as privileged.

Where the 93% figure comes from

The motion builds the number from Meta’s own re-review results, excluding documents Meta identified as duplicates:

  1. Priority index: 727 of 926 documents downgraded, or 79%.
  2. First weekly tranche: 14,397 of 16,038, or 90%.
  3. Second weekly tranche: 56,747 of 60,462, or 94%.
  4. Cumulative: about 93% as of the November 13 filing.

Plaintiffs add that the special master further downgraded or narrowed Meta’s claims on nearly 10% of the sampled documents Meta still considered privileged, and that Meta has objected to 11 of those rulings. They also say the downgraded material includes internal research and chats about underage users and age verification, and documents suggesting the legal department shaped or restricted research rather than giving legal advice. Reuters reports that filings describe Meta making hats printed with “a/c priv” for a team working on Instagram’s teen accounts. Many of these passages are redacted in the public filing, and none has been tested in court.

Two caveats matter. First, 93% describes the documents Meta has re-reviewed so far, not every document in the case. Second, the motion itself quotes Meta as saying that, for the more than 56,000 documents in its latest and largest production, it has “not determined that these documents were incorrectly withheld or redacted.” Plaintiffs say that is because Meta used generative AI rather than human review for that batch while reserving the right to claw documents back under the case’s Rule 502(d) order.

What plaintiffs want the court to do

The sanctions sought target the trial rather than seeking a dismissal or a default judgment. Plaintiffs ask the court to:

  • let them use every document or passage released through the re-review with any trial witness, and bar Meta’s objections on authenticity, foundation, personal knowledge and other admissibility grounds, except Rule 403;
  • instruct the jury about Meta’s improper withholding and how it affected plaintiffs’ ability to develop evidence;
  • change the Rule 502(d) order so Meta needs the court’s permission, on a document-by-document showing of good cause, before clawing back anything released in the re-review;
  • order Meta to pay the reasonable fees and costs caused by its privilege assertions.

The motion argues that under Rule 37 Meta bears the burden of showing its conduct was “substantially justified” and that no finding of bad faith is needed, while acknowledging that sanctions under the court’s inherent power require conduct “tantamount to bad faith.” It also points to the Cambridge Analytica consumer privacy litigation in the same district, where a court in 2023 sanctioned Meta with fees after a re-review found privilege improperly claimed over 63% of a sample, part of the long tail of the Cambridge Analytica fallout.

Meta’s response

Meta has told the court it acted in good faith in withholding and redacting documents for privilege. A Meta spokesperson told Reuters the motion is “nothing but a litigation tactic by plaintiffs’ counsel trying to leverage routine discovery disputes into an advantage at trial.” Meta’s formal opposition is due December 2. Separately, on November 17 Meta filed notice of the special master’s Report No. 2, together with a motion to file it under seal, so the special master’s findings are still developing.

Why compliance teams should pay attention

This is a discovery fight, but it is built on how a company labels and stores its own records. The same pressure appears in other youth-safety litigation, from state attorneys general pursuing Meta over youth safety to parents suing Google over teen safety features, and the lessons travel well beyond social media:

  • Privilege is not a label. Copying a lawyer or stamping “privileged” on research does not make it legal advice. Courts look at whether the communication was made to obtain legal advice.
  • Research on minors is evidence. Internal studies about young users, age verification and safety features are now central to litigation and to state laws such as New York’s Child Data Protection Act. Write them assuming they will be read in court.
  • AI-assisted review needs human backstops. According to plaintiffs, the court declined to let AI narrow the review set, and they now attack AI-only downgrades. Leaning on AI without sound data governance can create risk rather than save time.
  • Fix governance before litigation. Clear records classification, retention rules and legal-hold procedures, the basics of records and data governance, are far cheaper than re-reviewing tens of thousands of documents under a special master.

FAQ

Has the judge sanctioned Meta?

No. The motion is pending. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers is scheduled to hear it on December 14, 2026, and Meta has not yet filed its formal opposition.

Did Meta withhold 93% of all documents in the case?

No. The 93% is plaintiffs’ calculation of how many documents Meta has downgraded in its re-review so far, excluding duplicates. For its latest production, Meta has said it has not determined that the documents were incorrectly withheld or redacted.

Who is overseeing the re-review?

Retired Magistrate Judge Suzanne H. Segal, appointed as special master. She checks weekly samples of documents Meta still claims as privileged.

What would a jury instruction do?

If granted, the jury would be told about Meta’s improper withholding and its effect on plaintiffs’ ability to gather evidence. The court decides whether and how to word any such instruction.

When is the next trial?

Reuters reports the next federal trial, set for February, will test a school district’s claims against Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap. Meta must finish its re-review by December 30, 2026.

A privilege log is a promise

Every entry on a privilege log tells the court that a lawyer gave or was asked for legal advice. If the court accepts plaintiffs’ account that tens of thousands of those promises did not hold, the cost to Meta will be measured in what a jury is told in February, not in a fine. For every other company, the takeaway is to decide now how you label, store and review sensitive internal research, because a court may later make you prove every label.