Know what is on your site before a plaintiff’s firm does.Free website scanScan Your Site
Log in Sign up Book a demo
Home› News› CalPrivacy Fines Polaris $910,986 and Minnesota Takes $150,000…
NEWS

CalPrivacy Fines Polaris $910,986 and Minnesota Takes $150,000 in Joint Opt-Out Case

Polaris Industries, the Minnesota-based maker of snowmobiles, off-road vehicles and boats, will pay a combined $1,060,986 to settle a joint privacy investigation by California’s privacy agency and Minnesota’s attorney general.

Nov 20, 2026 7 min read

Polaris Industries, the Minnesota-based maker of snowmobiles, off-road vehicles and boats, will pay a combined $1,060,986 to settle a joint privacy investigation by California’s privacy agency and Minnesota’s attorney general. The California Privacy Protection Agency, now branded CalPrivacy, announced on November 19, 2026, that its Board had adopted a decision requiring Polaris to pay a $910,986 administrative fine under the California Consumer Privacy Act. The same day, Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison announced a $150,000 settlement under the Minnesota Consumer Data Privacy Act, his office’s first enforcement action under that law. The most useful detail for anyone running a website is not the dollar amount. It is how California counted the violations: at least five for every visit by a consumer who had already opted out.

TL;DR

  • CalPrivacy’s Board adopted a stipulated order on November 13, 2026, requiring Polaris to pay $910,986 and fix how it handles opt-outs; it was announced on November 19.
  • Minnesota’s attorney general reached a $150,000 Assurance of Discontinuance with Polaris, the first enforcement action under the Minnesota Consumer Data Privacy Act.
  • The California order says Polaris required email verification for opt-outs, did not honor opt-out preference signals, and kept sending data to ad-tech firms after opt-outs; Polaris neither admitted nor denied most findings.

Two regulators, one investigation

According to CalPrivacy’s announcement, its Enforcement Division and the Consumer Protection Division of the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office ran the investigation together. Both are members of the Consortium of Privacy Regulators, the bipartisan group of state enforcers that Minnesota joined as it expanded. The order says Polaris created a single settlement fund for a global resolution of both states’ claims, then signed separate papers with each regulator: a Stipulated Final Order in California (Case No. ENF25-128-R-PO) and an Assurance of Discontinuance in Minnesota.

The newsletter summary described the outcome as a finding that Polaris’s practices “allegedly violated” both laws. The precise status is a settlement. The California Board adopted the stipulated order as its decision on November 13, 2026. Under it, Polaris admits only basic facts about the company, the agency’s jurisdiction and the existence of the joint investigation; it neither admits nor denies the remaining factual findings and does not admit liability. Minnesota’s release describes what its office “discovered,” but the resolution there is also a negotiated settlement, not a court judgment.

What California says went wrong

The stipulated order covers July 1, 2023, to April 30, 2026, and sets out four problems.

  • Opt-outs required verification. Consumers who used Polaris’s “Individual Rights Request” form to opt out were told to follow emailed instructions and warned that no identity validation response within 10 days would cancel the request. Those who never replied received an email saying their identity could not be verified. CCPA regulations at 11 CCR section 7026(d) prohibit requiring a verifiable consumer request for an opt-out. The order records that Polaris did not intend to require verification and later processed the requests.
  • The privacy policy was silent on opt-out preference signals. Section 7011(e)(3)(F) requires businesses to explain how they process signals such as Global Privacy Control. Polaris’s policy did not address them.
  • Signals were not honored. Some tracking technologies on Polaris sites were not configured to process opt-out preference signals, so data kept flowing to ad-tech companies.
  • “Decline All” did not decline all. The “Your Privacy Choices” pop-up offered “Accept All” and “Decline All.” The agency observed in 2026 that clicking “Decline All” on one site fired the Meta pixel, sharing personal information with Meta at the moment the consumer tried to refuse.

The verification issue is not new. CalPrivacy noted that it had already addressed the same problem in its decision against Ford Motor Co. If your opt-out form sends a confirmation email that must be answered before anything happens, that is now a well-documented enforcement target. Our guide to CCPA requests explains why access, deletion and correction requests can be verified while opt-outs cannot.

The compounding math

The section that should get attention from marketing and engineering teams carries the heading “Polaris’s Sales and Shares After Consumers Opted Out Had a Compounding Effect.” The order explains that Polaris’s tags sent personal information to several ad-tech companies on each page visit, and that some tags directed browsers to one ad-tech company for cookie matching, also called cookie syncing, which then caused the browser to share data with more ad-tech companies.

California treats each sale or share to a third party after an opt-out as a separate violation of Civil Code section 1798.120(d). The order states that Polaris violated that section at least five times for each visit by an opted-out consumer, and at least five more times on each repeat visit. CalPrivacy’s Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement, Lara Kehoe Hoffman, put it plainly in the announcement: stacking up sales and shares after consumers have exercised their rights is a problem.

That counting method turns a single misconfigured tag into a per-visitor, per-vendor, per-visit exposure. It also explains why a company that was cooperative, as the order says Polaris was, still ended up with a near-seven-figure fine. Studies of sites that keep tracking after an opt-out suggest this is a widespread problem rather than a one-company error.

Minnesota’s first MCDPA action

The Minnesota Consumer Data Privacy Act took effect on July 31, 2025. Ellison’s release says his office found that Polaris denied opt-out requests when consumers did not confirm their identity by email, that some tracking technologies were not configured to process Global Privacy Control and similar signals, and that the privacy notice did not adequately disclose opt-out information required by the law. The release notes that while the MCDPA lets controllers authenticate identity for some rights, such as access, opt-out requests must be honored on receipt without additional steps. Ellison called the action a message to businesses still failing to comply, more than a year after the law took effect. For a refresher on the statute, see our Minnesota privacy law cheat guide.

What Polaris must do

Beyond the fine, payable within 30 days, the California order requires Polaris to:

  1. update its privacy policy to explain how opt-out preference signals are processed;
  2. offer opt-out methods that are easy and require minimal steps, without verification;
  3. keep a “Do Not Sell or Share” or “Your Privacy Choices” link that actually opts consumers out or takes them to a page where they can;
  4. scan and review its tracking technologies every quarter for three years to confirm opt-outs are passed to recipients;
  5. adopt an internal approval process for any new tracking technology, covering contracts and opt-out configuration;
  6. consult a technical specialist on its consent pop-up and signal handling;
  7. train staff who handle CCPA requests; and
  8. confirm completion within 90 days and file officer-signed compliance certifications annually for three years.

Minnesota’s Assurance of Discontinuance contains similar injunctive terms, according to both regulators.

Lessons for every site that runs ad tech

  • Test the button, not the banner. Click “Decline All” or “Reject” with network monitoring on and confirm no advertising pixel fires afterward, on every property and template.
  • Treat cookie syncing as a multiplier. One partner that syncs with others can turn a single failure into many violations. Know which of your vendors do it.
  • Remove verification from opt-outs. Ask only for what you need to identify the record, and process the request with what you have.
  • Make signal handling visible. Describe in the privacy policy how GPC is applied to the browser, device and any linked account, then make sure the tags behave as described. Our opt-out and GPC readiness guide walks through the testing.
  • Gate new tags. Polaris’s order requires approval before any new tracker goes live. That is a sensible control for anyone.
  • Plan for coordinated enforcement. CalPrivacy’s recent Hertz decision and this joint action show the same issues being pursued repeatedly, now across state lines.

Frequently asked questions

Did Polaris admit violating the CCPA?

No. Polaris admitted certain background facts but neither admitted nor denied the other findings, and it did not admit liability. It agreed to pay the fine and change its practices.

Why is Minnesota’s payment so much smaller than California’s?

The states settled separately under different laws. Neither regulator explained how its amount was calculated, and the California order says Polaris created a single settlement fund to resolve both investigations.

Can a business ask for an email address on an opt-out form?

California’s rules let a business ask for information needed to identify whose data to stop selling or sharing, but if it can comply without more, it must. Requiring the consumer to answer a verification email first is what got Polaris in trouble.

Is CalPrivacy working with other enforcers?

Yes. Polaris was investigated jointly with Minnesota through the Consortium of Privacy Regulators, and CalPrivacy has also partnered with California’s attorney general and district attorneys, including on a connected-vehicle case against General Motors.

Why this one matters

Polaris sells machines built for places without much traffic. Its website, according to the regulators, had plenty: data moving to ad-tech partners every time an opted-out visitor arrived. The fine is modest by national standards. The counting rule behind it is not, and with California and Minnesota now settling cases together, a broken opt-out is no longer a single-state risk.