Know what is on your site before a plaintiff’s firm does.Free website scanScan Your Site
Log in Sign up Book a demo
Home› News› Advocate General Medina: Facebook Is Not ‘Free’ When…
NEWS

Advocate General Medina: Facebook Is Not ‘Free’ When Users Pay With Their Data

Can a social network call itself free when users hand over their personal data to use it?

Nov 20, 2026 7 min read

Can a social network call itself free when users hand over their personal data to use it? According to Advocate General Laila Medina of the Court of Justice of the European Union, the answer under EU consumer law is no. In an opinion delivered on 19 November 2026 in Case C-643/25, she proposed that giving personal data and consenting to its commercial use counts as a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. The opinion is not binding, and the Court has only now begun its deliberations, but if the judges follow it, the word “free” will become much riskier for data-funded services across the EU.

TL;DR

  • Advocate General Medina proposed on 19 November 2026 that disclosing personal data and consenting to its commercial use is a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.
  • The case, referred by Germany’s Federal Court of Justice, concerns Facebook’s 2015 registration-page slogan “Facebook is and remains free,” challenged by the German consumer federation vzbv.
  • She also said the GDPR does not prevent consumer law from applying, but her opinion does not bind the Court, which will rule at a later date.

What the case is about

The dispute is older than most people would guess. In February 2015, Facebook’s registration page in the EU displayed the statement “Facebook is and remains free.” The Federation of German Consumer Organisations (Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband, or vzbv) objected, arguing that users were not getting the service for nothing, because they provided their personal data and agreed to its commercial use in return for access.

The lower German courts dismissed the claim, reasoning that the ban on calling a service free only applies when consumers bear financial costs. The vzbv appealed to the Bundesgerichtshof, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (case I ZR 11/20). According to the vzbv’s statement, the court stayed the case in September 2025 and referred questions about “paying with data” to Luxembourg, where it became Case C-643/25. Meta has since stopped using the slogan, the vzbv says, but refused to sign a binding cease-and-desist undertaking, which is why the case continued.

One correction to some early summaries: this case is not a direct challenge to Meta’s current pay-or-consent subscription model. It concerns a “free” claim in advertising and the meaning of payment under consumer law. Its reasoning is still highly relevant to pay-or-consent debates, as explained below.

What the Advocate General proposed

The Court’s press release on the opinion sets out her reasoning in several steps.

  1. Payment need not be money. The directive bans describing a product as “free” if the consumer has to pay for it. Medina found that the wording does not necessarily limit payment to money, and that the Court has already accepted that consideration can take other forms if it has economic value and a definite link to the commercial practice.
  2. Personal data has economic value. Users’ data, together with consent to its commercial exploitation, lets the operator earn advertising revenue and finance the service. The fact that users keep their data does not stop its commercial use from being payment.
  3. EU law already treats data as consideration. She pointed to the Digital Content Directive (2019/770) and the Consumer Rights Directive, which recognise services supplied in exchange for personal data. It would be inconsistent, she said, to treat such deals as involving consideration in those laws but allow the same services to be presented as free under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.
  4. Consumer protection points the same way. Limiting payment to money would weaken protection in the digital economy, where users may not understand the value of their data or how far it is used for advertising.
  5. There is a narrow exception. A service can still be described as free if the data is processed exclusively to provide the service or to comply with legal obligations.

The practice at issue sits on the directive’s blacklist, the list of practices banned in all circumstances. That matters because, as the Advocate General noted, blacklisted practices do not require a case-by-case test of whether the average consumer was actually misled.

Meta’s arguments, and why they failed

The opinion rejects three lines of defence:

  • The blacklist should be read narrowly. The list is exhaustive and only the legislature can add to it, she agreed, but that does not mean the terms on the list must be interpreted narrowly.
  • The GDPR already covers this. Medina said the GDPR governs lawful and transparent processing of personal data, while the directive governs the accuracy of commercial claims. The two apply cumulatively.
  • It restricts business freedom. Not so, in her view. Companies can still offer services in exchange for data. They just cannot call them “free” when that consideration is required.

The GDPR point is the one privacy teams should note. It means a data practice can be lawful under data protection law and still produce a consumer law violation in how it is marketed. Consumer authorities and consumer associations, not only data protection authorities, could then be in a position to act.

Pay-or-consent models offer users a choice between paying a subscription and accepting personalised advertising based on their data. The model has been under pressure from several directions. In 2023 the Court of Justice, in its ruling in Meta v Bundeskartellamt, said users who refuse consent to certain processing should be offered an equivalent alternative, if necessary for an appropriate fee. In April 2025 the European Commission found that Meta had breached the Digital Markets Act by failing to give users a real choice of a service using less of their personal data, and consumer groups have challenged similar models from publishers.

Medina’s reasoning adds a consumer-law layer to that debate. If the Court agrees that data plus consent is payment, then the “consent” tier of a pay-or-consent model is not a free tier at all. It is a different way of paying. Businesses would need to describe it that way in marketing, onboarding and app store listings. The opinion does not decide whether any current Meta offer is unlawful, and it does not address the DMA or GDPR consent questions directly.

The vzbv says a second case it brought against the discounter Lidl over price transparency in a data-for-discounts app (I ZR 198/25) has also been stayed at the Bundesgerichtshof to await this ruling. Loyalty apps and “free with registration” offers could be next in line.

What businesses should review now

The judgment may be months away and could differ from the opinion. Still, a few low-cost checks make sense for anyone offering data-funded services in the EU:

  • Audit the word “free.” Look at landing pages, sign-up flows, ads and app store copy for “free,” “kostenlos,” “gratuit” and similar terms on services that rely on personal data for advertising or other commercial use.
  • Map what the data is for. The exception only covers data processed exclusively to deliver the service or meet legal obligations. Data used for ads, profiling or sale falls outside it.
  • Align consent and marketing. Make sure the value exchange described in your GDPR consent management matches what your marketing says. A banner that explains data use for ads sits awkwardly next to a headline saying the product costs nothing.
  • Revisit your consent model. The choice between opt-in and opt-out consent models already varies by market. In the EU, also consider how each tier of a subscription or rewards offer is labelled.
  • Watch AI features too. Services that use interaction data to personalise ads or train models, part of a broader push into AI personalisation, face the same question if they are promoted as free.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a final ruling against Meta?

No. An Advocate General’s opinion is an independent proposal to the Court. The judges are only beginning their deliberations, and the Court often, though not always, follows the opinion. After the ruling, the German court will apply it to the facts.

Does the opinion ban services funded by personal data?

No. Medina said businesses remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data. The issue is how they describe them, specifically whether they can call them “free.”

Why does a consumer law case matter to privacy teams?

Because it means GDPR compliance is not a complete defence. The GDPR and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive would apply side by side, so consumer regulators and associations could act on misleading claims about data-funded services.

How do Advocate General opinions usually play out?

They often shape the final judgment but do not bind it. A recent example is the opinion on Google Fonts, IP addresses and GDPR damages, which set out a view the Court still has to accept or reject.

The price of a word

For a decade, “free” has been the default label of the consumer internet. This opinion suggests EU law may soon require a more honest description: you are paying, just not in euros. Companies that rewrite that word on their own terms now will have an easier time than those forced to do it after the Court rules.