Eight years after the District of Columbia sued Facebook over the Cambridge Analytica scandal, the case is finally headed to a jury. Judge Robert Okun of the D.C. Superior Court denied Meta’s bid to win the case without a trial on November 6, 2026, and at a hearing on November 12 set a jury trial to begin on July 12, 2027. Early summaries said the judge “dismissed” Meta’s efforts to resolve the lawsuit. More precisely, he denied Facebook’s motion for partial summary judgment, ruling that the key disputes are questions of fact for jurors. Nothing has been decided against Meta yet, and the company denies wrongdoing.
TL;DR
- A D.C. Superior Court judge denied Facebook’s summary judgment motion on November 6, 2026, holding that a jury must decide whether its privacy disclosures and omissions around Cambridge Analytica could mislead reasonable consumers.
- The trial is set for July 12, 2027, and the District’s case against Facebook has been consolidated with its separate 2022 lawsuit against Mark Zuckerberg.
- The ruling follows a 2025 appeals court decision that revived the case by lowering the District’s burden of proof for unintentional misrepresentation claims.

What the judge decided
The District’s lawsuit, filed in December 2018 under the D.C. Consumer Protection Procedures Act (CPPA), alleges that Facebook gave users a false impression about who could access their information and failed for years to disclose that data had been improperly obtained by Cambridge Analytica, the political consulting firm. Facebook denies the allegations.
In his November 6 ruling, as quoted by MLex, Judge Okun wrote that “genuine issues of material fact remain on whether Facebook’s disclosures concerning friend sharing, its enforcement of its platform policies, and the Cambridge Analytica Incident had a tendency to mislead a reasonable consumer, and on whether the challenged representations and omissions were material. Those questions are for the jury.” Reuters reported that he also found “the District has produced evidence that consumers care deeply about the privacy and control of their personal data.”
A summary judgment denial is not a finding that Meta broke the law. It means the judge concluded there is enough evidence on both sides that a reasonable jury could go either way, so the case cannot be resolved on paper.
How the case got here
The road to a trial date has been long, and one appellate ruling changed its direction.
- December 2018: The District, then led by Attorney General Karl Racine, sues Facebook under the CPPA following the Cambridge Analytica revelations.
- 2022: The District files a separate CPPA lawsuit against Mark Zuckerberg personally, over his oversight of the company’s data protection practices.
- 2023: Superior Court Judge Maurice Ross grants summary judgment to Facebook. He applied a “clear and convincing evidence” standard and concluded that because Facebook’s policies accurately disclosed friend sharing, no reasonable consumer could have been misled as a matter of law. He also excluded the District’s only expert witness, privacy researcher Dr. Florian Schaub.
- July 31, 2025: The D.C. Court of Appeals reverses. It holds that CPPA claims based on unintentional misrepresentations need only be proved by a preponderance of the evidence, sends the summary judgment question back, and reverses the blanket exclusion of the expert for further analysis.
- November 6, 2026: Applying the lower standard, Judge Okun denies Facebook’s motion.
- November 2026: MLex reports that Okun consolidated the Facebook case with the Zuckerberg suit and lifted a stay that had held the Zuckerberg case back. At the November 12 hearing he set the July 12, 2027 trial date and said he would consider whether to try the two cases together, according to Reuters.
- July 12, 2027: Scheduled start of the jury trial.
Facebook is represented by Gibson Dunn. Reuters reports that Zuckerberg’s team includes Jonathan Kravis and Jessie Liu, a former top federal prosecutor in D.C., who joined the case in October.
What the District claims, and what it must prove
The appeals court opinion summarises the District’s theory in three parts. It says Facebook unintentionally misled consumers about which of their data third-party apps could reach through their friends’ accounts, misled them about its ability to audit and police those apps, and made a material omission by not telling users that their data had been obtained in breach of Facebook’s own policies.
At trial the District will need to persuade jurors, on the balance of probabilities, that those statements and omissions had a tendency to mislead a reasonable consumer and were material. Before it was reversed, the 2023 trial court sided with Facebook on these points, concluding that its policies disclosed the relevant terms accurately and that it had no duty to disclose the incident; Facebook can be expected to press similar arguments before the jury. The CPPA lets the Attorney General seek remedies such as civil penalties, restitution and injunctive relief; what the District ultimately asks a jury and the court to award will become clearer as trial approaches.
Where this sits among Cambridge Analytica cases
The D.C. case is among the Cambridge Analytica matters still open in the United States, and earlier ones show the range of possible outcomes:
- Federal Trade Commission, 2019: Facebook agreed to a $5 billion penalty and a revised consent order with new privacy oversight requirements.
- Consumer class action: Meta agreed in late 2022 to pay $725 million to settle the federal consumer class action in California over third-party access to user data. As with any settlement, it was not an admission of liability.
- New Mexico, 2026: A state jury in September found that Meta’s Facebook violated New Mexico’s Unfair Practices Act 43,899,725 times. On October 21 the court ordered $25 billion in civil penalties, according to the New Mexico Department of Justice, a figure Reuters also reported. Meta denies wrongdoing and has said it will appeal.
New Mexico’s result shows how a state consumer protection statute, applied per violation, can produce numbers far beyond typical privacy fines. We looked at how that statute works in our piece on New Mexico’s Unfair Practices Act and privacy claims. The D.C. jury will hear a different case under a different law, so the New Mexico figure is not a guide to what D.C. might award.
Why this matters beyond Meta
For most businesses, the important point is not the size of Meta’s exposure but the legal theory. State attorneys general increasingly pursue privacy problems as consumer deception, without needing a dedicated privacy statute. Recent actions, from the GM driver data settlements to Kentucky’s lawsuit against Temu, follow the same pattern, and the overall tally of state privacy penalties in 2025 shows how much money is now involved.
The D.C. appellate ruling also matters. By allowing unintentional misrepresentation claims to be proved on a preponderance of the evidence, it makes it easier for the District to bring cases where a company’s statements were technically accurate in fine print but misleading in their overall impression. Practical takeaways:
- Accuracy in the policy is not the whole test. The jury question is whether statements and omissions, taken together, could mislead a reasonable consumer.
- Enforcement claims are representations. Saying you audit partners or police your platform invites scrutiny of whether you actually do.
- Known incidents create disclosure pressure. The District’s omission theory turns on what the company knew and did not tell users.
- Audit public statements regularly. A recurring privacy policy compliance audit that checks claims against real practices, including help-centre pages and settings screens, is the most direct defence.
- Keep the policy current. Sustaining privacy policy compliance means updating disclosures as data flows to partners change.
Frequently asked questions
Has Meta been found liable in the D.C. case?
No. The judge only ruled that the dispute must go to a jury. The allegations remain unproven, and Meta denies them.
Why did the case take so long?
Facebook won summary judgment in 2023, and the District had to appeal. The D.C. Court of Appeals reversed in July 2025, sending the case back for the ruling Okun made this month.
Is Mark Zuckerberg a defendant?
Yes, in a separate 2022 lawsuit that has now been consolidated with the Facebook case. Whether both will be tried together has not been decided.
Could the case still settle?
Yes. Nothing prevents the parties from settling before July 2027, as Meta did in other Cambridge Analytica matters.
Does the New Mexico penalty bind the D.C. court?
No. It was decided under New Mexico law by a different court and is under appeal.
A 2018 scandal with a 2027 court date
Cambridge Analytica has become shorthand for a past era of loose platform data sharing, but the legal consequences are still arriving. When a D.C. jury is seated next summer, it will be asked a simple question that every company publishing a privacy policy should ask itself today: would an ordinary user, reading what we say, understand what we actually do?