Know what is on your site before a plaintiff’s firm does.Free website scanScan Your Site
Log in Sign up Book a demo
Home› Editorial› Where the EU-US Data Privacy Framework Cases Stand…
GDPR

Where the EU-US Data Privacy Framework Cases Stand Now, and What Transfer Teams Should Prepare

The EU-US Data Privacy Framework is now more than three years old, and it is still in force.

Nov 20, 2026 8 min read

Know what’s on your site before a plaintiff’s firm does

A free privacy audit shows which cookies, pixels and trackers are running — and which ones commonly appear in privacy claims.

Get My Free Audit

The EU-US Data Privacy Framework is now more than three years old, and it is still in force. Nothing in the litigation around it has changed that, and the institutions that run it have proposed no change. Still, a privacy team cannot plan on the status quo alone. Three separate proceedings, one in Luxembourg, one in Washington and one inside the European Commission, could each change how the framework is judged. This guide sets out where each one stands in November 2026, what could happen next, and what transfer teams can prepare now so that a bad ruling becomes a project rather than a crisis.

TL;DR

  • French MP Philippe Latombe’s appeal against the General Court’s September 2025 ruling upholding the framework (Case C-703/25 P) is still pending at the Court of Justice, with no hearing or Advocate General opinion announced.
  • The D.C. Circuit heard argument on November 17, 2026 in LeBlanc v. PCLOB, the challenge by two removed members of the US privacy oversight board that the framework describes as part of its safeguards.
  • The European Data Protection Board asked the Commission in July 2026 to assess whether the Supreme Court’s Trump v. Slaughter ruling on FTC independence affects the adequacy decision, and no change to the decision has been announced.

Why the framework still works today

The framework rests on Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795 of July 10, 2023. Under Article 45 of the GDPR, that decision allows personal data to flow from the European Economic Area to US organizations that have self-certified to the framework’s principles with the Department of Commerce, without further transfer tools. An adequacy decision stays valid until the Commission amends, suspends or repeals it, or the Court of Justice annuls it. Neither has happened.

That point is easy to lose in the noise. A pending appeal does not suspend the decision. A letter from the European Data Protection Board does not suspend it. A US court ruling about a US agency does not suspend it. Each of these can raise the risk that the decision will change later, which is why they deserve tracking, but none of them changes the legal basis for a transfer made today.

Case 1: Latombe’s appeal at the Court of Justice

Philippe Latombe, a member of the French National Assembly, challenged the adequacy decision soon after it was adopted. On September 3, 2025, the General Court dismissed his action in Case T-553/23. He appealed on October 31, 2025. The notice of appeal published in the Official Journal lists the Commission, Ireland and the United States as the other parties and asks the Court of Justice either to annul the adequacy decision itself or to send the case back to the General Court.

The appeal raises four grounds, and they show where the legal pressure sits:

  • Judicial independence. The first ground argues the General Court was wrong to accept the rules for appointing and dismissing judges of the Data Protection Review Court, the US body that handles EU complaints about signals intelligence.
  • “Established by law.” The second argues that the review court, created by executive order and Justice Department regulation rather than by statute, is not a tribunal “previously established by law” under Article 47 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights.
  • Bulk collection. The third argues that US law does not subject bulk collection to prior authorization by a court or independent body, and that the General Court misread Schrems II and the La Quadrature du Net rulings.
  • Presidential power. The fourth targets the President’s ability to update the list of purposes for which bulk collection is permitted.

Appeals to the Court of Justice are limited to points of law. As of mid-November 2026, no hearing date or Advocate General opinion has been made public. An opinion usually comes some months before a judgment, so watch for it as the first real signal of which way the case is moving. The case runs on the court’s own clock, and nobody can reliably predict a judgment date.

Case 2: LeBlanc v. PCLOB in the D.C. Circuit

The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board is an independent US agency that reviews counterterrorism programs, including surveillance under Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The adequacy decision cites it as one of the oversight bodies that check US intelligence agencies. On January 27, 2025, the President removed the board’s three Democratic members without cause. Two of them, Travis LeBlanc and Edward Felten, sued, arguing that the statute did not allow removal at will. A federal district court ruled in their favor in May 2025 and ordered reinstatement, and the government appealed.

The D.C. Circuit put the appeal on hold in October 2025 to wait for the Supreme Court’s ruling in Trump v. Slaughter. Once that decision came down on June 29, 2026, the court returned the case to its active docket and asked for supplemental briefing. It heard oral argument on November 17, 2026, before Judges Henderson, Pillard and Edwards, according to the court’s argument recordings list (No. 25-5197). The government argues that Slaughter controls. The former members argue that Congress deliberately removed the earlier “serve at the pleasure of the President” wording when it rebuilt the board in 2007.

For EU transfers, the outcome matters less for the board’s quorum than for what it says about independence across the US oversight system. A ruling that PCLOB members are removable at will would be one more fact the Commission must weigh in its monitoring.

Case 3: Trump v. Slaughter and the Commission’s own review

In Trump v. Slaughter, the Supreme Court held that the President can remove Federal Trade Commissioners at will. The FTC is the main US enforcer of the framework’s commercial principles, and the adequacy decision describes its commissioners as removable only for “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office.” On July 31, 2026, EDPB Chair Anu Talus wrote to Commissioner Michael McGrath asking the Commission “to closely assess” whether the ruling affects the decision and to keep sharing information with the Board in a timely manner.

The ruling did not change the FTC’s powers to investigate and enforce, and the Commission has said it is analysing the judgment’s implications without proposing any change to the decision. The real question is whether independence is judged by formal removal protections or by how enforcement actually works, and the answer may come at a predictable moment. The Commission’s first periodic review, in October 2024, set the next review for three years later, which puts it in 2027. That review is the natural moment for the Commission to address Slaughter, the PCLOB case and any developments in Section 702 together.

What could happen, from least to most disruptive

  1. Nothing changes. The Court of Justice dismisses the appeal, the Commission’s 2027 review confirms adequacy, and certified companies carry on.
  2. The decision is updated. The Commission amends recitals that no longer describe US law accurately, records new US commitments, or adds reporting conditions. Transfers continue.
  3. Partial suspension or conditions. The Commission limits the decision’s scope or attaches conditions under its monitoring powers. Some transfers may need another tool.
  4. Annulment. The Court of Justice annuls the decision, as it did with Safe Harbor in 2015 and Privacy Shield in 2020. Transfers that rely only on the framework lose their basis.

The fourth scenario is the least likely in the near term, but it is the one that justifies preparation. In 2020, the Court gave companies no grace period after Schrems II: the Privacy Shield decision was invalid from the day of judgment.

What transfer teams should prepare now

The goal is not to stop using the framework. It is to know, for every US transfer, what you would do the day after a ruling.

  • Map which transfers depend on the framework alone. Many vendor contracts already include the EU standard contractual clauses (Commission Decision (EU) 2021/914) as a backup, while others rely only on the recipient’s certification. Your data mapping should show which is which.
  • Check certifications, not just contracts. A recipient’s listing on the Department of Commerce’s Data Privacy Framework List must be active and must cover the type of data you send, such as HR data. Lapsed or narrow certifications are a common gap.
  • Keep transfer impact assessments current. If you rely on standard contractual clauses, your assessment of US law should reference Executive Order 14086, the review court and the status of Section 702. Under the EDPB’s recommendations on supplementary measures, an assessment written in 2022 and never updated is hard to defend.
  • Pre-negotiate fallback clauses. Where a contract relies only on the framework, add standard contractual clauses that take effect if the adequacy decision is suspended or annulled. Negotiating this calmly now is far easier than negotiating it with hundreds of vendors at once.
  • Know your supplementary measures. For high-risk flows, identify where encryption with keys held in the EU, pseudonymization or data minimization could reduce exposure.
  • Assign a monitor. Someone should watch the Court of Justice docket for C-703/25 P, the D.C. Circuit for the LeBlanc decision, and the Commission for its 2027 review.

It also helps to see this framework as one of several. The EU keeps adding adequacy arrangements with other countries, and its data protection authorities are increasingly willing to investigate transfers directly, as the Irish inquiry into transfers to China showed. EU-US data cooperation also extends beyond commercial transfers. The EDPS recently set out safeguards for a separate EU-US border data agreement, a reminder that EU bodies are reviewing several transatlantic data arrangements at once.

Frequently asked questions

If the Court of Justice rules against the framework, will there be a transition period?

Do not count on one. Neither the 2015 nor the 2020 judgment included a grace period. Regulators showed some practical tolerance, but the legal basis disappeared on the day of judgment.

Do standard contractual clauses avoid the problem entirely?

No. They are a separate legal tool, but the same questions about US surveillance law feed into your transfer impact assessment. A ruling that criticizes US safeguards would make those assessments harder to write, not irrelevant.

Does the PCLOB case have to finish before anything changes?

No. The three proceedings are independent. The Commission can act on its own monitoring at any time, and the Court of Justice will decide Latombe’s appeal on the record before it.

Should a company stop self-certifying?

There is no legal reason to. Certification remains valid and keeps the simplest transfer route open. The better step is to make sure your GDPR compliance program would survive the framework’s loss.

The bottom line

Every EU-US transfer mechanism so far has been tested in court, and the two before this one failed. This framework has already passed its first test, and it may pass the next. The companies that get through 2027 calmly will be the ones whose fallback plan is ready before it is needed.

Put this into practice

Turn privacy guidance into working controls.

Captain Compliance helps teams discover tracking technologies, enforce consent, manage privacy requests and document the evidence behind every decision.

Book a demo Run a free scan