Texas Takes on Allstate: Lawsuit Alleges Misuse of Driver Data

Table of Contents

The State of Texas has filed a lawsuit against Allstate Insurance, alleging the insurance giant unlawfully collected and misused driver data through its subsidiary, Arity. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton claims that Allstate and Arity paid millions of dollars to mobile app developers to integrate tracking software into their platforms. This software secretly collected extensive driving data from unsuspecting users, including information on speeding, sudden braking, and phone usage while driving.

Arity could certainly use a data privacy software solution and a team of compliance superheroes to come in and help right about now. 

This data was then allegedly used by Allstate to assign “risk scores” to drivers, ultimately impacting their insurance premiums. In some cases, the lawsuit alleges, this data was used to deny coverage or even cancel policies.

“Allstate and Arity paid millions to mobile app developers to incorporate tracking software into their apps,” stated Attorney General Paxton. “This resulted in the sale of millions of Americans’ private data to insurance companies, all without proper disclosure or consent. Texans deserve transparency and accountability, and we intend to deliver just that.”

Allstate vehemently denies these allegations. In a statement, the company emphasized its commitment to compliance with all applicable laws and regulations. They assert that Arity’s data collection practices are transparent and consent-based, providing accurate and fair insurance pricing for consumers.

Arity, described as possessing the “world’s largest driving behavior database,” collected data from popular apps like Life360 and GasBuddy. This data, encompassing driving habits of over 45 million Americans, was allegedly used to inform underwriting decisions and potentially influence insurance premiums.

The lawsuit, filed in Montgomery County District Court, accuses Allstate and Arity of violating Texas privacy laws by collecting and using user data without their explicit knowledge or consent. This action follows a similar lawsuit filed against General Motors last year by the Texas Attorney General, alleging that automakers were selling driver data to insurance companies without proper disclosure. You can be assured that more and more of these lawsuits will pop up for privacy violations as we’re only getting more privacy laws not less.

These lawsuits highlight a growing concern among regulators and consumers regarding the collection and use of personal data by large corporations. As technology advances and data becomes increasingly valuable, the need for robust data privacy protections and consumer safeguards is more critical than ever. The outcome of this legal battle will have significant implications for the insurance industry and may serve as a precedent for future data privacy enforcement actions across the United States.

Written by: 

Online Privacy Compliance Made Easy

Captain Compliance makes it easy to develop, oversee, and expand your privacy program. Book a demo or start a trial now.